Preparing for a Nonprofit Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide

An audit doesn’t have to be stressful. For many small and mid-sized nonprofits, the anxiety surrounding audit season isn’t about the audit itself, but the scramble that comes before it: the hunt for documents, the reconciliation of records that went astray during the year, the effort to reconstruct decisions made months ago without adequate documentation.

The good news is most of that rush is avoidable. By methodically preparing for the audit in advance of the auditor’s arrival, nonprofits complete fieldwork faster, receive fewer findings and pay lower audit fees. This guide outlines the key steps and a handy Form 990 and audit checklist to help your organization get there.

Does Your Nonprofit Need an Audit?

Not every nonprofit has to go through an annual financial audit, but plenty of organizations find themselves needing one. Usually, it comes down to three main reasons:

  • Federal Funding: If your nonprofit spends $1 million or more in federal awards in a single fiscal year, you’ll need a Single Audit (also called an OMB Uniform Guidance audit) under 2 CFR Part 200. Keep in mind that this $1 million threshold took effect in 2024 and applies to tax years starting on or after October 1, 2024.
  • State Rules: Many states require audited financials before you can register to solicit donations. In Arizona, for instance, charitable organizations face specific registration and filing rules depending on their revenue. It’s always best to double-check the local guidelines in every state where you raise funds.
  • Funder or Board Requirements: Foundations and major donors often ask for audited statements before handing over grant funding. Your board’s own bylaws might also call for an annual audit, no matter what your revenue numbers look like.

 

Even if none of these triggers apply to you right now, you might still need a financial review or compilation. Touching base with a CPA at the beginning of each fiscal year is a great way to confirm where you stand.

Step 1: Start Early

The best move your nonprofit can make to ensure a smooth audit is to jump-start preparation well before the fiscal year wraps up. Ideally, getting audit-ready should be an ongoing habit throughout the year rather than a last-minute rush.

Three to six months before your audit fieldwork begins, the focus should be on:

  • Ensuring the chart of accounts is aligned with GAAP and Form 990 functional expense categories (program services, management and general, fundraising)
  • Reviewing grant agreements and confirming that restricted funds are properly tracked and spent in accordance with donor intent
  • Reconciling all balance sheet accounts, including bank accounts, investments, receivables, and payables
  • Confirming that board meeting minutes are complete and accurately reflect financial decisions, budget approvals, and audit committee activity

 

When you’re just a month out from fieldwork, your focus turns to pulling together the full document package and doing a quick last check to catch any missing pieces or mismatched details.

Step 2: Gather Your Documents

Your auditor will request a standard package of documents at the start of fieldwork. Having this ready before they arrive reduces delays and demonstrates organizational competence, both of which matter.

Financial Records

  • General ledger and trial balance for the full fiscal year
  • Bank statements and reconciliations for all accounts
  • Investment statements (12 months)
  • Budget-to-actuals comparison
  • Cash flow statements
  • Accounts receivable and payable aging schedules
  • Payroll records, including W-2s, 941s, and any 1099s issued
  • Prior three years of audited financial statements

Governance and Tax Records

  • Board meeting minutes for the full fiscal year
  • Conflict of interest disclosures for all board members and key employees
  • Current bylaws and articles of incorporation
  • IRS determination letter confirming tax-exempt status
  • Prior three years of Form 990 returns
  • Draft Form 990 for the current year, if prepared
  • Insurance policy declarations

Grant and Program Documentation

  • All active grant agreements and award letters
  • Grant drawdown records and expenditure reports
  • Restricted fund activity schedules showing opening balance, activity, and ending balance by fund
  • In-kind contribution documentation, including fair market value support for non-cash gifts
  • Documentation of any federal awards, if a Single Audit applies

Step 3: Review Your Internal Controls

Auditors evaluate not just whether the numbers are accurate but whether the organization has adequate processes in place to produce accurate numbers consistently. Weak internal controls are one of the most common audit findings for small nonprofits, and they are also among the most preventable.

Here are a few quick questions to ask yourselves before the audit team arrives:

  • Is there documented segregation of duties for cash handling, check signing, and bank reconciliation? In small organizations, this is challenging, but compensating controls (such as board review of monthly bank statements) should be in place and documented.
  • Are expense approvals documented, with appropriate authorization levels in writing?
  • Is there a written procurement policy, and is it being followed?
  • Are credit card statements reviewed and approved by someone other than the cardholder?
  • Is payroll reviewed and approved by someone independent of payroll processing?

 

If you can’t answer “yes” to all of these just yet, try to patch up those gaps before audit season begins. Even writing down a short summary of how your team handles these day-to-day tasks goes a long way.

Step 4: Prepare Your Form 990

While your Form 990 isn’t the audit itself, the two go hand in hand. Auditors almost always review your previous 990, and any discrepancies between your return and your financial statements can quickly trigger extra questions.

Here is a handy checklist of Form 990 items to double-check before fieldwork begins:

  • Confirm that total revenue, expenses, and net assets on the 990 reconcile to the audited financial statements
  • Verify that functional expense allocations (program, management, fundraising) are consistent and supportable
  • Review Schedule A to confirm public support calculations are accurate
  • Ensure compensation disclosures for officers, directors, and key employees are complete and accurate
  • Confirm that all required schedules are attached and complete (Schedule B for major donors, Schedule D for financial assets, Schedule F for foreign activities if applicable)
  • Have the draft 990 reviewed by the audit committee or full board before filing

 

Keep in mind that your Form 990 is a public document, so donors, grantmakers, and regulators can easily view it. Giving your 990 the same careful attention as your audited financial statements helps protect your nonprofit’s hard-earned reputation and standing.

Step 5: Communicate with Your Auditor

Audit fieldwork goes much smoother when nobody encounters sudden surprises. Before things get underway, set up a brief planning chat with your auditor to review the request list, confirm timelines, decide who on your team will be their main contact, and talk through any major updates from the past year.

It’s especially helpful to give your auditor a heads-up on key changes like new grants with unique terms, shifts in accounting practices, major purchases or loans, related-party transactions, or progress you’ve made on past audit recommendations.

The clearer the picture your auditor has upfront, the faster they can work—and the sooner you’ll have your finalized financial statements in hand.

How HBL Can Help

At HBL, we partner with nonprofits across Southern Arizona to guide them through audit prep, Form 990 filings, accounting advisory, and year-round financial management. Whether you’re getting ready for your very first audit, clearing up past findings, or looking for ongoing guidance to keep your finances audit-ready every day, our team is here to help you navigate your unique reporting requirements with confidence.

Ready to make your next nonprofit audit stress-free? Contact HBL today to get started.